Cavite vs Aamir: Cavite is Hands-Down Winner

Some get their highs from Snow White.

Some derive their highs via curry.

Some wet their thighs over Aamir.

Over the last couple of days, we watched both Cavite and its Bollywood spawn Aamir (you can stream them both on Instant Play, if you have a $8.99 Netflix subscription).

We watched the Tagalog language Cavite first. After all, it came three years ahead of Aamir (2008).

Except for the ending, Aamir is a clone of Cavite.

Given all the hype about Aamir in India (God, in that country you are a legend if you need only one hand to hold your dick while peeing), we expected a lot from Cavite.

Our logic: Why would a Bollywood film-maker borrow from a foreign movie unless it has something remarkable to offer.



Cavite is not a gripping thriller that has you going ‘wow’ at any point.

But it’s alright, a chalta hai kinda movie.

You don’t feel upset that you spent 1-hour 10-minutes watching it, the way you do at the end of most Bollywood or Kollywood films.

There’s a fair degree of urgency and tension throughout Cavite.

And the credit for that goes to Ian Gamazon, who plays the central character of U.S. based Adam coming to Manila to attend his father’s funeral only to find his mother and siblings held hostage by some Mindanao terrorists.

For the most part, the movie does hold your attention although at times we grew tired of the Turn right, faggot. Take that bus, faggot. Turn left in that alley, faggot.

Similar Story
Soon after he lands at the Manila airport, Adam (Ian Gamazon) is threatened by an unknown voice on the phone that his family will meet a dire fate if he doesn’t undertake some tasks.

Right from the moment the San Diego resident based Adam arrives in Manila, straggles through the foul slums of the city and all the way up to the end as he staggers away from the church, we found Gamazon’s character of Adam to be an endearing figure.

By the way, Gamazon is also the co-director and co-writer of Cavite along with Neill Dela Llana.

Only after watching the film did we learn that Cavite was made on a shoestring budget of $7,000.

That knowledge enormously increased our admiration for the incredible passion of the key people involved in making Cavite.

Aamir – Disappointing Fare
, on the other hand, has little going for it.

Save that a few prematurely-ejaculating Indians came even faster after watching this film.

Most Indians who go gag-ga over Aamir have most likely not heard of Cavite and even more likely don’t have access to the Tagalog film (our Netflix copy came with English sub-titles).

Used to the Bollywood balderdash of Akshay Kumar, Salman Khan, Shahrukh Khan et al, they are bedazzled at seeing a movie like Aamir that’s so different

Compared to Cavite, the Hindi film Aamir has just one thing in its favor – money. Apparently, the Hindi movie was made on a much higher budget of Rs 2 crore ($412,000), according to Wiki.

But Aamir has too many things in its disfavor – a poor script, mediocre acting by the lead character Rajeev Khandelwal and overall a crude finish.

The Bollywood spawn lacks the finesse and subtlety of the Talagog version.

You say subtlety has never been a feature of Indian movies?

True. But that doesn’t lessen the need for it.

Those two staring kids on the motorbike who hand over the cell-phone to Dr. Aamir Ali, the ‘psycho’ taxi driver, we found all of these and more to be extremely crude touches, needless and irritating.

After seeing Cavite, we couldn’t but be upset that the Hindi language Aamir seemed so contrived. All of it, the acting, photography and the script.

Showing the character of the voice on the phone in Aamir was a big mistake. That dramatically lessened the impact, lessened the tension and worse of all removed the menacing aspect of the caller/kidnapper, so evident in Cavite.

Even as he threatens our protaganist with dire consequences and gives bhashans of the poverty and sorry plight of Indian Muslims, our kidnapper is shown having a sumptuous lunch and playing with a young child. The disconnect seemed weird.

Also, Rajeev Khandelwal needs to go back to acting school.

Contrast for instance a conceptually similar scene in the two movies, both putting the central character in a desperate situation: Of Adam in Cavite stealing a cell-phone from a lady when his battery dies to Dr. Aamir Ali in Aamir when he loses his red suitcase and the subsequent fight.

While the short-scene was handled with a degree of finesse in Cavite, its Hindi equivalent was needlessly drawn-out, way too long and completely butchered.

Turned out really ugly, particularly Dr. Aamir Ali’s fight with the three ruffians.

Its many shortcomings aside, Aamir is still a welcome respite from the endless run of pathetic Bollywood movies like Singh is Kinng, Wanted, Kambhakkht Ishq et al.

3 Responses to "Cavite vs Aamir: Cavite is Hands-Down Winner"

  1. kennedy   October 9, 2009 at 1:09 am

    His name is Rajeev Khandelwal. I think his acting was fine as in compared to other so called superstars. He tends to be over intense at times, maybe because he happened to be a soap actor prior to the movie. And you’ve got to see one to get a whiff of the shit which goes down here on television. By that standards he has done a hell of a job.

    The primary reason of liking the movie is because it was a welcome change as u have stated.

    Plus it had a very beautiful song ‘Ha rahem – Mehfuz’ which i loved. To point out a fact the music director of the movie happens to be the music director of Dev D as well. If u have seen Dev D which was a good movie with nice music. It’s director is Anurag Kayshap ( Black Friday, Gulaal his two other outstanding movies.) Responds:

    1. We agree. Rajeev Khandelwal is a lot better compared to the superstar buffoons clowning around.

    We also liked the fact that right at the outset, the Aamir folks acknowledged Ian Gamazon and Neill Del Llana.

    2. We’ve seen Dev D and liked it a lot but never got around to reviewing it. One of these days, we will. It deserves to be more widely known.

    3. BTW, have you seen Cavite?

  2. kennedy   October 10, 2009 at 2:23 am

    Sure Dev D and “super star actor” Abhay Deol sure deserve to be reviewed. I enjoyed his oye lucky lucky oye, it’s also a very refreshing movie like Khosla ka Ghosla (have veterans Anupam kher and Boman Irani). Both movies are by the same director Dibankar Banerjee.

    Well I was waiting for your thoughts on movie Maqbool by Vishal Bhardwaj. It’s an adaption of Macbeth, as like his another movie Omkara which is inspired by Othello.
    I ve mentioned quite a lot movies here. 🙂

    I haven’t seen Cavite but i’ll watch it this weekend. Responds:

    Dev D definitely deserves a review. But we have so much on plate that we’ve been deferring it.

    Haven’t seen Maqbool but Omkara review is here.

  3. vjcool   October 26, 2009 at 8:14 am

    Have you seen ‘Pan’s Labyrinth’? A really good watch..don’t read the wiki entry, it’ll spoil the film.
    the film has elements of war, fairy tales, social commentary.. and not for children Watching this movie made me want to watch ‘The Devil’s Backbone’ another similar movie by ‘Guillermo del Toro’.. someday maybe.. after I watch inglorious basterds and Gran torino Responds:

    You write: Have you seen ‘Pan’s Labyrinth’?

    Yes, we’ve watched it.

    Beautiful movie.

    We can still see the little girl moving about in the labyrinth. Those scenes were like a masterpiece painting.

You must be logged in to post a comment Login